Nikole Hannah-Jones’ school choice for her daughter sparks a debate over Black parents, education and sacrifice

The acclaimed author and Pulitzer Prize winner’s candid account of educating her daughter in New York City public schools has sparked an intense conversation about race, privilege and parental responsibility.

Nikole Hannah-Jones‘ personal essay about her daughter’s education, a decade-long follow-up to her original 2016 piece, quickly went viral over the weekend. Jones, the Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist behind “The 1619 Project,” revealed she enrolled her daughter in one of New York City’s public schools that had been segregated by several existential factors, namely wealth, class and race under the guise of “school choice.”

However, her daughter challenged her, asking why Jones and her husband couldn’t send her to better, well-funded schools if they had the means?

The decision by Jones and her husband, Jones argued, was one of obligation to the community they belonged to. It’s a common topic of conversation in Black households across the country: If possible, do we send our child to the best schools where they will be academically challenged, or to the ones where their cultural and educational needs will be met? In some cities, that question determines where people live, what zoning loopholes they would break and more, all to pursue what they deem is “best” for their child.

Jones opted to send her daughter to certain schools up until high school, when she tested and was accepted to one of the hardest schools to get into. Still, toward the end of the piece, Jones admits that she felt her daughter “got cheated” out of the education she deserved.

Her daughter responded, “Sometimes I wish instead of always thinking about other kids, you would have thought about me. I never really got the education I wanted.”

What should have been a moment about parenting and, more broadly, the lack of educational reinforcers in schools in New York City and possibly elsewhere, turned into an attack on Jones personally and a complex conversation that held varying opinions, thoughts and beliefs about what was right, wrong and how Jones’ vulnerability was somehow lost in all of it.

Some held their critiques in fairness. An educator took to Threads and wrote, “If I ever had the opportunity to speak with Nikole Hannah-Jones, I would want to ask her, honestly and without judgment: What role did the possibility of public backlash play in the decisions you made for your daughter? If you had chosen a highly resourced school, did you fear that people would accuse you of betraying your work, abandoning your principles or advocating publicly for one set of children while privately securing something different for your own?”

In other moments, individuals who had experienced the cruelty of “school choice” spoke up on Jones’s behalf, unwilling to conflate money with better.

“I am appalled by the number of Black women attacking @nikolehannahjones MOTHERING because of the educational choice she made for her daughter,” one user wrote. “We can honor her daughter’s critique AND interrogate academic gaps. But this idea that money + assimilation was obviously the better choice? How dare you flatten Black education like that.”

Others centered their thoughts on a simple phrase: “case study.” Jones, in their eyes, used her own child as a thought experiment.

“The same woman who wrote The 1619 Project used her child as a case study at a failing school to uphold her own ideals to the detriment of her child’s education,” a woman, who graduated from schools in Arkansas, wrote on Threads, questioning what Jones and her husband were doing at home and curious as to why she didn’t have the curiosity to wonder what was going on with their child in school.

View on Threads

“I get that she wanted to be transparent about her daughter’s educational journey and the choices they made to course correct, but that article made my head hurt,” Lews added.

The conversation prompted Jones herself to respond online, whether she once more brought up that she wasn’t merely looking out for her daughter’s future, but for the future of Black students who looked like her daughter across her community.

“The fact that so much of the discourse around my essay is about me “sacrificing” my child with absolutely no concern for, nor mention of, all the other children in these schools my daughter went to, is breathtakingly sad,” Jones wrote. “Appalling really. I don’t regret, and won’t ever regret, caring about more than my own child. There is nothing self-righteous about that.”

View on Threads

For now, Jones’ daughter is a few years away from graduating high school and free to make another decision: which college would be best for her. Jones’ choices might have opened up a massive can of worms for many a parent, but it’s a decision that not every Black household will readily stick to the same script.