Judge orders partial release of records tied to FBI search of Ilhan Omar’s home
The Justice Department can keep most of the search warrant affidavit sealed, but records related to Omar’s constitutional protections will
The Justice Department can keep most of the search warrant affidavit sealed, but records related to Omar’s constitutional protections will be made public.
The public will get a partial look at how federal agents handled the search of Rep. Ilhan Omar’s home, but not at the evidence behind it.
At a hearing Tuesday, Chief Judge James E. Boasberg sided with the Justice Department on keeping the “vast majority” of the search warrant affidavit under seal, NBC News reported. He called full disclosure “premature.” He drew a line, however, at the legal back-and-forth over protecting Omar’s rights as a sitting member of Congress. “All of the legal debate about speech and debate, I don’t believe that should be redacted,” Boasberg said.
That clause of the Constitution shields lawmakers from being “questioned in any other Place” over their legislative speech, a protection meant to preserve Congress’ independence from the executive branch.
Federal agents searched Omar’s Washington, D.C., home in October, just weeks before the election, and seized her phone. Magistrate Judge Matthew Sharbaugh authorized the search and set protocols to guard Omar’s congressional privileges, but those safeguards were never made public.
Boasberg made clear he had reviewed the filings and saw little justification for secrecy. Most of the litigation documents, he said, contain almost nothing about investigative facts or witnesses.
Justice Department attorney Alessandra Serano acknowledged that some speech-and-debate material could be released and said prosecutors are still reviewing what agents seized.
The department did want to keep the nature of any potential charges sealed. Boasberg found that hard to square with what the administration has already said publicly. People familiar with the case have told NBC News the investigation centers on possible immigration-related crimes. Vice President JD Vance has publicly said he believes Omar committed immigration fraud.
“We’ve got your superiors saying what the government is looking into,” Boasberg told Serano. She replied that she had no control over those statements. “That seems to be a common refrain,” the judge said, laughing.
Omar, the first Somali American elected to Congress, is a naturalized citizen who came to the U.S. as a child. No charges have been announced.
After the search, she called it an attempt to “weaponize federal law enforcement” against political enemies and said Trump had targeted her for a decade with baseless attacks. She won reelection earlier this month.
The overt search of a sitting lawmaker’s home so close to an election remains highly unusual. Boasberg’s ruling won’t reveal the government’s case, but it will show the public how the courts tried to balance a criminal investigation against the constitutional protections Congress relies on.
Share
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Angry
0
Sad
0
Wow
0